I see Seattle’s public schools from two sides. My husband and I own a pottery studio in Seattle, and Cedar Park Elementary in Northeast Seattle hired us to teach a pottery program during its IDEA (Investigate, Design, Engage, and Ask Why) time. Our two children attended Seattle Public Schools, but a model built almost entirely around studying for tests didn’t work for them. They moved to Summit Public Schools, where they are now in middle and high school. Both experiences have convinced me that students don’t have to choose between rigorous academics and learning driven by their own interests.
That matters right now. Cedar Park is one of 21 Seattle public schools under review for closure or merger, and it may be merged with James Baldwin Elementary as soon as the 2027-28 school year.
In his Oct. 25 newsletter to the community, Superintendent Ben Shuldiner offered a striking admission:
“Decisions seemed to be made in direct opposition to the expressed needs of our community. When parents asked for rigor, we thought of cutting advanced programming. When families asked for clarity, they got obfuscation. When we hear about the desire for more arts, music, and dual language programs, we seem to cut those first.”
His candor is welcome. But these are not isolated mistakes. They reflect a long-standing problem at the core of public education: the perceived conflict between standardized testing and personalized learning.
Many treat the two as competing priorities, where time spent on one is time taken from the other. I believe students need both, and our schools can offer both. But each depends on a culture that supports it. Our school board, district leadership and teachers unions are structured around standardized testing, not the culture that personalized learning requires.
Cedar Park shows what bridging that gap looks like. Classroom teachers cover core subjects and testing. During IDEA time, the school brings in outside specialists like us to lead hands-on learning in our fields. In our pottery program, one student created outstanding airplane models in clay. The school’s staff were excited: His interest and engagement far exceeded anything they had seen from him in academic classes.
The results are encouraging. According to the school, over the past three school years Cedar Park students have scored an average of 7 percentage points above the district average in math, 10.7 points above in English language arts and 11.4 points above in science on state assessments.
Summit, a charter network with two public schools in Seattle, applies a similar idea to middle and high school. Alongside core academics, its “Expeditions” time brings in teachers and community experts, to lead students in exploring their interests and potential careers. Summit reports that 96% of its graduates are accepted to a four-year college and that its alumni finish college at nearly twice the national average.
I know charter schools are contentious in Washington. My point is not that Seattle should become a charter district. It’s that this model doesn’t require one. Cedar Park is already doing it inside Seattle Public Schools.
The reason it works is simple. When students recognize their own interests, passions and curiosity, they start to see how their studies serve them in the long run. Core academics stop feeling like obstacles imposed on them and become a foundation for what they truly care about.
Superintendent Shuldiner says our schools exist to serve students. If so, the district should understand what is working at schools like Cedar Park before merging them away, and make it the standard in every building.
Closing schools may ease the district’s budget problems, but it does not address the root issues in public education. To reverse declining enrollment, the system needs to innovate by offering both rigor and passion, and real hope for students and their families.
