Sorry Rachel, Gavin, Bernie and all the other liberal pundits and progressive Democrats who have been excoriating the eight senators who cut a deal with Republicans to end the government shutdown — sorry, but you are wrong.
What exactly was the end game you had in mind? Did you honestly think Republicans who barely care if the government operates at all would finally capitulate and restore the health care benefits that Democrats were fighting to preserve? Did you think the Decorator-in-Chief who is busy remodeling the White House in the image of a chintzy Versailles would suddenly care about the plight of poor people and grow a heart?
Yes, Democrats swept pretty much every election from governors’ races to school boards all across the country last week, but those victories did not come because Democrats were manning the health care ramparts. It came because a motivated majority of voters are repulsed by President Donald Trump and his abuses of power, and that disgust spilled over into local politics everywhere.
Sure, according to polls, more voters blamed the GOP for the government shutdown, but polls can shift quickly. Positive polls are no guarantee of anything; ask Hillary Clinton.
In fact, the Senate Democratic caucus defectors did their colleagues a big favor. The shutdown was beginning to do serious harm to federal workers who were being fired or forced to work without a paycheck, and to recipients of essential benefits that enable them to buy food for their families. That pain was only going to spread to many other Americans, and some of the blame would have begun to fall on Democrats, too.
For political gain, the shutdown had gone on long enough. From a weak position as the minority caucuses in Congress, the Democrats successfully brought the health care crisis to the forefront in a distracted society where it is hard to get anyone’s attention. They put Republicans on the defensive and, now, votes are lined up that will put GOP senators and representatives in the crosshairs on the health care issue — an issue that is not going to disappear just because the government has reopened.
Raw politics would dictate that being able to continue pinning the blame for drastic hikes in health care premiums on Republicans as we roll into an election year is a big plus for Democrats. Sure, in an ideal world where virtue triumphs, it would be a finer thing if the D’s could have made the R’s do their bidding, but, guess what? That was never going to happen.
Democrats made their point. The shutdown needed to end. The timing was right. Eight senators who are not up for reelection next year are taking the blame, but, arguably, they should be getting our thanks instead.
See more of David Horsey’s cartoons at: st.news/davidhorsey
View other syndicated cartoonists at: st.news/cartoons
Editor’s note: Seattle Times Opinion no longer appends comment threads on David Horsey’s cartoons. Too many comments violated our community policies and reviewing the dozens that were flagged as inappropriate required too much of our limited staff time. You can comment via a Letter to the Editor. Please email us at letters@seattletimes.com and include your full name, address and telephone number for verification only. Letters are limited to 200 words.
