Ever since our human ancestors started drawing on the walls of caves, art has had the power to enchant and delight us but also the potential to seduce us into thinking, even doing, terrible things. According to a Roman legend, the first Greek sculpture of a naked woman — Praxiteles’ “Aphrodite of Knidos,” from the 4th century B.C.E. — was so stunningly lifelike that one man had sex with it, left his stain upon it and then, in shame, threw himself off a cliff. The pulsating eroticism of later paintings in the Italian Renaissance, with their quivering flesh and dripping sensuality, was believed to be capable of fomenting erotic desire through beautified sexual violence. In the mid-18th century, the pious Duke of Orléans attacked Correggio’s mythological painting “Leda and the Swan” with a knife because he was so offended by its steaminess.
The infamous “moors murders” of 1960s Manchester — in which Ian Brady and Myra Hindley sexually assaulted and murdered five children — were partly inspired by the 18th-century novels of the Marquis de Sade. Sade’s writings eroticize pedophilia, coprophilia and necrophilia (as well as essentially everything else) and are grounded in a libertine, amoral system: Pleasure and pain are the only real values; morality is merely manufactured to control society. While Brady claimed to hold similar beliefs before he read Sade, he still considered himself one of Sade’s depraved heroes, inspired by the French nobleman’s work. The sheer brutality of Sade’s stories meant that his novels — along with many other literary and visual artworks that contained explicit sexual material or then-subversive themes like queer love — were widely censored across the world until the late 20th century. Liberalizing changes in obscenity law in many countries, including the United States and Britain, solidified the idea that a ban could not be carried forward if the art in question had some kind of value for society. Now, you can buy Sade’s novels from most major bookstores.
Depravity, of course, is hard to define. In my work as a philosopher, I define “depravity” around an objective (im)morality. Moral objectivists like me think there are ethical facts independent of our fleeting beliefs about what is wrong or right: Rape and enslavement are wrong and always have been, even if some people once thought otherwise. Where to draw that objective line is an ongoing debate, but most objectivists would agree that much of what appears in art, from Sade to Grand Theft Auto, would qualify as depraved.
Art is rarely neutral. It is very much alive, subtly shaping the world in its image. And the idea that video games can cause real-world violence by urging virtual misdeeds has become something of a cliché, but the premise is well established. Aristotle theorized that we may become what we behold in art. Pliny the Elder wrote that one Greek sculptor’s bronze statue of a lame man was so realistic that it caused viewers’ feet to become sore. This “mimetic contagion,” as explored by classicist Robert Germany, meant that viewers could absorb the ethical and emotional qualities of art. Even music, to ancient philosophers like Plato and Mozi, was dangerous: It could spur listeners to unmeasured emotion, or even induce chaos.
Mimetic contagion may seem antiquated, but the ever-blurring line between fiction and reality makes it easier than ever to immerse ourselves in pretend worlds. Virtual reality and artificially generated images and videos are eroding our ability to easily distinguish the real from the fictitious.
