I’m in a lot of conversations about housing. And sometimes they give me a knot in my stomach.
Recently, I sat around a table with nonprofit affordable housing leaders, real estate developers, public officials and other advocates discussing Seattle’s Mandatory Housing Affordability requirements, and whether they should be reduced temporarily to restart stalled market-rate projects.
The MHA debate traps Seattle between how to restart these stalled construction projects while at the same time protecting affordable housing resources for our lowest-income neighbors.
It’s a fact that stalled projects are part of the equation, as they represent as much as $90 million in MHA contributions that Seattle will never collect on if those projects aren’t built. On top of that, proposed legislation would reduce contributions from projects that make construction progress of at least 80% over the next two to three years.
The reality for developers in our region is that the cost of land, construction, labor and financing have all risen dramatically. Developers say that the projects that used to work for them several years ago no longer pencil out, and I believe them. But I also know that Seattle needs market-rate, affordable and permanent supportive housing to solve our housing crisis.
Every dollar that Seattle invests in affordable housing can attract roughly three additional dollars from other public and private sources. Losing $72 million locally could mean losing nearly $290 million in total investment, enough to help build approximately 1,200 affordable homes.
While Mayor Katie Wilson has proposed a budget that maintains significant annual investments in affordable housing, it also cuts $65 million in previously allocated housing resources to close the city’s budget gap, a quiet move representing the largest cut to any city agency. The reality is that having $65 million less to invest in affordable housing over time is a significant loss right now, a moment when thousands of our neighbors are struggling to find a home that they can afford.
Our city’s budget is a statement of our values, particularly when resources are scarce. We can’t claim that affordable housing is a top priority in Seattle while continuing to chip away at the resources and tools needed to build it. With additional reductions to the MHA now under consideration, we risk compounding the problem even more, and that’s why I believe that any MHA reduction should be temporary, transparent and paired with at least $50 million in replacement funding from the city. Any choice to reduce critical sources of affordable housing funding must have a credible plan to replace what is being lost.
It’s important to point out that changes to MHA requirements are not the first (or only) place the city can look for solutions. The city has long known that permitting delays, complex regulations and rising costs make housing harder and more expensive to build. The mayor’s proposed permitting reforms and Affordable Housing Ombuds are steps toward addressing those problems, but proposals alone won’t get housing built. Our community needs to move faster in delivering meaningful reforms before asking its lowest-income neighbors to bear the cost of making market rate housing development more financially viable.
This debate cannot be separated from Seattle’s history of exclusion and displacement. Native people were among the first pushed out, then redlining excluded Black, Asian, Jewish and other families from entire neighborhoods. More recently, growth has displaced many Black families from the Central District and pushed workers farther from the city.
The consequences of letting affordable housing resources disappear fall disproportionately on the communities that have repeatedly been priced out or pushed out of Seattle. That’s why this conversation isn’t just about economics or development, it’s a moral test for Seattle. MHA requirements help organizations like Community Roots Housing serve neighbors living on very low incomes, people exiting homelessness, families, elders, people with disabilities and workers who keep our city running. Organizations like ours serve the people that the private market is leaving behind.
Right now we don’t have the luxury of choosing between building housing and affordability, so we need to create the conditions for investment and development while protecting resources, like MHA, that help our most vulnerable neighbors remain here. That’s the Seattle we should choose to build.
