A high-profile effort to donate one of Washington’s major newspapers to a nonprofit has imploded, following a personnel dispute involving the editor who crafted the plan.
The Spokesman-Review announced Tuesday that editor Rob Curley had “departed,” following an investigation into newsroom complaints and a leadership clash that erupted during coverage of the Spokane fires in August.
Publisher Stacey Cowles told the newspaper that plans to donate the paper to Comma, a Spokane nonprofit founded by Curley, are now over.
The Spokesman’s initial, online report on Tuesday said Cowles was still open to transferring the paper to a nonprofit. But that wasn’t mentioned in a later, updated version, which reported that the newspaper “will remain part of the Cowles Co.”
The decision was praised by the newsroom union, which characterized the outcome as Stacey Cowles siding with employees who had lost faith in Curley.
“There was no way it was going to work if Curley was allowed to manage us the way he had been allowed to manage the newspaper,” said Thomas Clouse, a senior reporter and president of the newsroom’s union.
A message seeking comment from Curley was not returned before my deadline.
Curley had pitched the donation to Comma as a model for other legacy publications. He announced the plan at a newspaper industry conference in Florida on April 15, 2025.
Instead, it became a cautionary tale about how internal friction and overlapping interests can complicate the transfer of a community institution to a fledgling nonprofit.
“If there’s a nonprofit and the management of that nonprofit doesn’t jibe with the working journalists that are in that room, how do you make that work?” said Kip Hill, a Spokesman veteran now teaching journalism at Gonzaga University.
The messy breakup could make it harder to raise further donations in Spokane, though the passions involved demonstrate how much people care about saving their newspaper.
The situation also highlights one of the reasons more than three papers a week close in America, leaving millions of people with little to no local news coverage: It’s hard to find new owners, especially for independent publishers wanting to see their newspapers remain locally owned and not merged into cost-cutting chains.
A majority of the roughly 300 newspapers that closed or merged since 2024 were independently owned or private, midsize chains. Fewer than 15% of America’s daily newspapers are independently owned, according to research by Northwestern University’s Medill School.
In Spokane, the Cowles family has owned The Spokesman for 132 years but none of its younger generation wanted to become the next publisher, Stacey Cowles told me last year. The family sold its printing operation last year, outsourcing production to Idaho. It also owns a paper mill, the last newsprint producer in the United States, that’s increasingly being used to produce packaging material.
In early 2025 the family agreed to donate The Spokesman and $2 million to Comma if the community raised at least that much to help sustain the newspaper.
Fundraising took longer than expected but last May the paper reported that $1 million in cash was raised, along with pledges for another $1 million, which was enough for the transfer to proceed.
But the deal was repeatedly delayed as details were negotiated.
Meanwhile tensions were building in the newsroom as Curley went ahead and involved Comma employees in operations, according to a report by Investigate West and RANGE Media.
That peaked in August with a leadership disagreement that led to Curley being suspended and an investigation being commissioned. Cowles has declined to publicly share the investigation.
Cowles did not return calls seeking comment before my deadline. His news release said The Spokesman is “doubling down on its community vision in the wake of Executive Editor Rob Curley’s departure” on Nov. 13.
That departure “follows differences over the Company’s core values, policies and code of conduct,” it said.
Work toward the transition was continuing until recently, with a target date of Dec. 1, according to Clouse. He said that before Tuesday’s announcement, computer and email systems were in the process of being transferred to Comma.
Curley was the sticking point in recent negotiations. Comma agreed to have a new editor and publisher but wanted Curley to remain in charge of strategy and web development, according to George Brunt, an attorney chairing the Comma board.
Brunt pointed to Comma’s news release, saying the Cowles Company would not give the paper to Comma if Curley remains part of the organization. Comma’s board “has declined to accept the gift of the newspaper on that condition,” it said.
“We can’t build Rob’s model without Rob. And no charity’s board should let a donor decide who leads it,” the release said.
As for the money donated by around 800 community members, Brunt said he’s waiting to hear whether they’d like it returned or used to support other Comma programs, such as a book club and community forum. As of Wednesday morning he hadn’t yet heard of any refund requests.
“I want to hear from the donors what they want to see,” he said.
Several board members of Comma left for different reasons as the drama escalated, Brunt said, but seven remain at the nonprofit.
“Almost everybody on the board are retired people who were trying to live a quiet, retired life,” he said, “not necessarily be thrust into the public spotlight over stuff like this.”
