Close Menu
    National News Brief
    Tuesday, November 17
    • Home
    • Business
    • Lifestyle
    • Science
    • Technology
    • International
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Sports
    National News Brief
    Home » We were wrong about being able to ‘nudge’ people to improve the world

    We were wrong about being able to ‘nudge’ people to improve the world

    Team_NationalNewsBriefBy Team_NationalNewsBriefJanuary 25, 2026 Science No Comments4 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email


    Our environmental and social problems are pressing and, in many countries, money is short and politics deadlocked. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if there turned out to be a new way of making real progress cheaply and without getting enmeshed in party politics?

    About two decades ago, along with many of our colleagues in the behavioural sciences, we thought there might be. The idea was elegant: social problems often arise from people making the “wrong” choices, either for themselves (eating unhealthily, smoking, gambling – the list goes on!) or for others (by, for example, damaging the environment by dropping litter). The old-fashioned approach to bad choices is to tax them or ban them. But the new strategy aimed for a gentler, more psychologically subtle approach: to redesign the way options are presented so the “right” choice becomes easy, natural and appealing. The bad choices are still available, but the clever policy ensures they are picked less often.

    Such “nudges” seemed to offer the hope of addressing big social problems through small changes to reshape individual behaviour. Worried about rising obesity? Try smaller portion and plate sizes, and move the salad bar to the front of the cafeteria. Concerned about climate change? Put homeowners on “green energy” by default.

    For a while, it appeared that a nudge revolution might be on the cards. An army of researchers (including us) searched for small tweaks to “choice architecture” that could drive changes in individual behaviour and make a big difference for society. Now was our chance to use psychological insights for a better world.

    If only. Nearly 20 years on, the results have been few and disappointing: even where nudges work, their effects are small, fade quickly and typically don’t scale up. And it turns out that by reinforcing the idea that social problems should be seen through the lens of individual behaviour, researchers have inadvertently provided ammunition for powerful business interests that oppose the old-fashioned (but effective) policy tools of tax and legislation that fundamentally change the system of rules and incentives that shape society – and could threaten their bottom line.

    With hindsight, none of this should have surprised us (though it did). The social problems we face have arisen not from changes at the individual level, given human psychology is surely largely constant over history. Instead, they have resulted from seismic systemic changes, such as mechanisation and electrification powered by coal, oil and gas over two centuries, or the rise of ultra-processed foods over the past 40 years. These shifts aren’t the responsibility of individuals – and individuals, however well they may be nudged, can’t alone fix the problems of carbon emissions or unhealthy diets. Indeed, there is a real danger that the individual focus is a distraction, misleading policy-makers and citizens alike into thinking there is a viable alternative to those laws and taxes.

    If we are right, we might expect corporations fighting regulation to be particularly active in inventing ineffective but plausible-sounding individual-level solutions. But wait – this has already happened. Consider the personal “carbon footprint” to help us track our individual damage to the planet. Where did this idea come from? The UN? Greenpeace? No, it came from a huge ad campaign in the early 2000s from one of the world’s largest fossil fuel companies, BP.

    Whatever the social or environmental problem, opponents of systemic change want to push that problem back to the individual. As behavioural scientists, we have fallen into the trap. No longer.

    Behavioural scientists Nick Chater and George Loewenstein’s new book is It’s On You (WH Allen), out on 27 January

    Topics:



    Source link

    Team_NationalNewsBrief
    • Website

    Keep Reading

    Neanderthal DNA linked to lower risk of schizophrenia in modern humans

    Voyager 1 approaches a ‘light-day’ milestone

    Can the Amazon rainforest survive the largest El Niño in living memory?

    The neuroscience behind stuttering | Scientific American

    Record-breaking simulation sheds light on cosmic ‘dark ages’

    Why your brain sometimes craves sour tastes

    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    Editors Picks

    Trump, Israel’s Netanyahu meet for a second time about a ceasefire in Gaza | Israel-Palestine conflict News

    July 9, 2025

    Child and mother among 6 struck by taxi that veered onto sidewalk in Manhattan

    December 26, 2024

    It’s a bird! It’s a plane! It’s the most expensive comic book ever sold

    November 25, 2025

    Opinion | ‘God’s Not Doing Everything, but There’s Something Mysterious’: A Q&A With Nick Wolterstorff

    March 2, 2025

    Why a Peruvian mountain is becoming an ‘impossible’ particle detector

    March 12, 2026
    Categories
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Business
    • International
    • Latest News
    • Lifestyle
    • Opinions
    • Politics
    • Science
    • Sports
    • Technology
    • Top Stories
    • Trending News
    • World Economy
    About us

    Welcome to National News Brief, your one-stop destination for staying informed on the latest developments from around the globe. Our mission is to provide readers with up-to-the-minute coverage across a wide range of topics, ensuring you never miss out on the stories that matter most.

    At National News Brief, we cover World News, delivering accurate and insightful reports on global events and issues shaping the future. Our Tech News section keeps you informed about cutting-edge technologies, trends in AI, and innovations transforming industries. Stay ahead of the curve with updates on the World Economy, including financial markets, economic policies, and international trade.

    Editors Picks

    Madison Huang, Jensen Huang’s Daughter, Became a Powerful Force at Nvidia

    November 17, 2026

    Market Talk – November 16, 2026

    November 17, 2026

    Jason Sudeikis And Hannah Waddingham Praised For ‘Chemistry’

    November 17, 2026

    Commentary: Microsoft outage shows that big tech can’t be treated as too big to fail

    November 17, 2026
    Categories
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Business
    • International
    • Latest News
    • Lifestyle
    • Opinions
    • Politics
    • Science
    • Sports
    • Technology
    • Top Stories
    • Trending News
    • World Economy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms and Conditions
    • About us
    • Contact us
    Copyright © 2024 Nationalnewsbrief.com All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.