Minnesota Vikings head coach Kevin O’Connell believes franchises bail on their struggling young quarterbacks too often. That didn’t stop him from abandoning the J.J. McCarthy experiment.
The Vikings traded the 23-year-old QB to the New York Giants on Monday for a 2027 fifth-round pick. For a guy who preaches patience, O’Connell sure isn’t exercising it. Few teams have punted on developing a QB taken in the top 10 of the NFL Draft as quickly as Minnesota is giving up on McCarthy (pick No. 10 in 2024).
J.J. McCarthy joins bad company after trade to Giants
Per Josh Dubow of the Associated Press, McCarthy has become the sixth QB taken in the top 10 in the common draft era (since 1967) to make 10 or fewer starts for their original team. None of the five other QBs Dubow listed became a franchise player.
McCarthy missed his rookie season after suffering a season-ending right knee injury in preseason. Despite making a Pro Bowl in 2024, the Vikings let Sam Darnold join the Seattle Seahawks in free agency and handed the keys to McCarthy. He flopped.
