Presidents do not get to choose which reporters cover them. On Thursday, a federal judge reaffirmed that fundamental principle.
President Donald Trump had banned CNN, MS NOW and Politico from the White House, calling them “FAKE NEWS” in his social media announcement. The White House pulled hard-pass credentials from those outlets’ journalists and made it clear they were not welcome among the pool reporters, in briefings and everywhere else the president goes.
The news organizations promptly sued, and U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly ordered the passes restored. He did so with care, applying court precedents dating back five decades. He concluded that the news outlets are likely to prevail on their claim that their passes were revoked without the notice and hearing required by the Fifth Amendment’s due process clause.
The administration tried to claim a national security justification for the ban, but Kelly saw through that flimsy rationale.
Kelly kept his order narrow. It restores the journalists’ passes for 14 days, while both sides brief the court on whether a preliminary injunction is justified. Such orders are generally unappealable, though Trump vowed to appeal.
Hours after the order, the administration rebuffed journalists from CNN and MS NOW when they showed up to cover Chinese President Xi Jinping arriving for a state dinner Thursday. The White House let in reporters from other networks. No one should miss the irony of an American president shutting out reporters he does not like while hosting a foreign leader whose government is among the world’s leading jailers of journalists.
The First Amendment prevents the government from punishing the press for coverage that officials dislike, including a president who wants only flattering stories. As Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash., wrote on X after Trump’s announcement, “Presidents with nothing to hide don’t ban reporters.” Few Republican members of Congress have spoken out against the ban.
Trump nominated Kelly to the bench in 2017, but before last week’s hearing he called him “totally disloyal.” Kelly is loyal to the Constitution and the American people, not to a president who disregards both.
