In every corner of the state, Washington families are being pushed to the edge of what they can afford. The cost of everyday necessities continues to ratchet up, while soaring energy costs make matters worse. But we shouldn’t have to struggle to keep the lights on, and we certainly shouldn’t have to keep paying volatile fossil fuel prices when cheaper, cleaner energy options are available.
If state regulators approve Puget Sound Energy’s current rate hike proposal without making key needed changes, energy costs will rise even higher. PSE is seeking a staggering 29% rate increase over the next three years, which means the average residential customer would owe an extra $51 a month for electricity and an extra $23 a month for their gas bill by 2029.
For years, opponents of a clean energy future for Washington have used fearmongering to tell us we must keep investing in outdated, expensive energy solutions like gas power plants. Kurt Miller in his op-ed correctly recognized we have significant challenges ahead to meet the Pacific Northwest’s growing energy demand, but he’s wrong to point to the Centralia coal-to-gas conversion as the solution. (“If not natural gas from Centralia, then what will keep the lights on?” Nov. 10)
PSE customers should understand that one of the main reasons for the utility’s big price hike is its misguided commitment to expensive, outdated and dirty fossil fuel infrastructure, including a huge proposed investment in Centralia.
Instead of fully committing to a clean energy transition, PSE plans to spend billions of ratepayer dollars purchasing power from a polluting, inefficient gas turbine installed at the defunct Centralia coal plant. On top of that, PSE is seeking customer funds for two additional gas-fired turbine projects without firm plans of where these turbines would even be sited.
Building new gas-burning infrastructure has never been a worse investment. Construction costs for gas power plants are at a 10-year high and surged 66% between 2023 and 2025 alone. As the clean energy transition continues to provide cheaper, more reliable energy and efficiency improves, these multimillion-dollar fossil fuel assets will become uneconomical and stranded long before the end of their expected life spans.
Fossil fuels also carry hidden costs beyond construction. Methane gas prices are notoriously volatile, tied to supply-chain bottlenecks, pipeline leaks and global market shocks. Fossil fuels are highly susceptible when there’s a crisis halfway around the world. Local renewable energy, on the other hand, offers a more reliable, predictable way to keep the lights on.
Unfortunately, the true costs of the Centralia conversion remain shrouded in secrecy and hidden from the public due to PSE’s designation of the information as highly confidential. Confidentiality designations allow PSE to effectively silence opposition to this massive fossil-fuel expenditure and prohibit a transparent comparison to cleaner alternatives. Typically, a project like this would have been compared to alternatives in a competitive bidding process — and that didn’t happen here.
Thanks to rapid technological advances, the cost of generating clean energy has hit historic lows. Solar, wind and battery storage are not only cheaper and faster to construct than fossil fuel facilities, but their fuel — sunshine and wind — is completely free and infinite. It will take investment to make this transition, but once built, clean energy infrastructure keeps long-term power costs stable and low.
To answer the question Miller asked in his op-ed, there isn’t one magic bullet that will build the energy future we need for the Northwest. It will require careful planning and implementation of multiple solutions simultaneously, including an ambitious build out of renewables alongside increased energy efficiency, long-overdue updates to our grid, and better management of when we use electricity, known as demand response. Environmental organizations like ours understand there may be a role for new peaker gas plants in the transition, but our review of the evidence shows that PSE left good options on the table and is pursuing expensive, inefficient new gas generation instead.
Serving 1.25 million electric customers and 900,000 gas customers, PSE holds immense power over our state’s economic and environmental future, but so does the public, and the Washington Utilities and Transportation Commission. The UTC is now weighing public comments and arguments made by intervenors like us in its rate case. (Learn more at st.news/rates)
We want the UTC to reject the unjustified rate hikes and hold PSE accountable to Washington’s climate laws. To keep rates reasonable and achieve a secure and affordable energy future, we must stop wasting customer money on expensive, climate-harming fossil fuel infrastructure that will grow in expense over time and eventually become obsolete. Clean, reliable, affordable energy is the path we must take to maintain a livable future.
