There is no question that Washington’s youth prison system badly needs an overhaul. That’s been true for the better part of a decade. The trouble now is not vision, so much as timing.
Last year, after constant reports of overcrowding, riots, staff burnout and mounting legal settlement payouts, lawmakers finally demanded a top-to-bottom assessment of the state’s Juvenile Rehabilitation facilities. That report arrived in October, and it’s a doozy.
It has prompted Tana Senn, secretary of the Department of Children, Youth and Families, to request nearly a half-billion dollars for new prison construction and renovation over the next decade. In the fine print, Senn notes these investments should enable JR to “expand capacity” beyond the 400 people it currently holds.
That will likely concern advocates for youth. But it should also worry lawmakers facing a multibillion-dollar budget shortfall and demands from Gov. Bob Ferguson that all state agencies trim spending by at least 10%.
Senn’s vision is ambitious. It involves shutting down one lockup, refurbishing and reopening another, establishing a brand-new site east of the mountains, and creating one more exclusively for young women and girls. It also recommends moving boys under 18 out of the chronically overcrowded Green Hill School and onto the campus at Echo Glen Children’s Center, then creating a series of smaller, group homestyle dorms back at Green Hill for older residents.
Some of these ideas have merit, particularly the push toward smaller facilities, which typically have better outcomes. But the plan raises real questions about decision-making on incarcerated youth to this point.
For example, lawmakers spent $33 million to transform a segregation unit at Stafford Creek prison, which houses adults, into a purported leadership academy for young men from Green Hill — over sustained outcry from parents and advocates, who called it “putting lipstick on a pig.”
Now, just two years later, Senn recommends shuttering that project and spending $40 million more to retrofit another adult prison for roughly the same number of youths?
The secretary declined multiple requests to discuss her vision with the editorial board. But the gist is that Washington’s juvenile prisons today hold a dramatically different population compared to a few years ago — older, convicted of more serious crimes and serving longer sentences.
Well, yes. That was the whole plan behind “JR to 25,” the suite of laws aimed at keeping young people in juvenile facilities until their mid-twenties. It shouldn’t have been a surprise.
The idea — or rather, the promise — of those laws was that these youths would get schooling and job training in a therapeutic setting. Clearly, that has not happened. Young people are so unhappy at Green Hill and Echo Glen that many with adult sentences are opting to go to prison early, due mainly to boredom. Turns out, education and vocational programs run by the Department of Corrections are better.
“There’s supposed to be some rehabilitation going on, but they’re just sitting around, wasting away,” said a member of the education team at Echo Glen who recently resigned in frustration.
That is the true tragedy of JR to 25. A plan based on good intentions and scientific research was set up to fail young people and taxpayers. In the last two years, the state has paid out $52 million in legal settlements from our youth prisons.
Digging out of this mess will cost a whole lot more.
