Washington’s commitment to clean energy shouldn’t come at the expense of working families and other ratepayers. But there is reason to worry that it will continue to inflate electricity rates, putting greater financial pressure on individuals and families while threatening Washington’s economic competitiveness.
Knowing how legislative decisions affect affordability, we need to understand what’s driving these increases, which are coming on top of higher housing, grocery and transportation costs, and whether Olympia’s energy policies are doing enough to protect the people paying for them.
For decades, utility regulation in Washington focused on affordable and reliable electricity. The Legislature’s 2019 passage of the Clean Energy Transformation Act changed that by adding ambitious mandates. At the time, the late state Sen. Doug Ericksen — then Republican leader on the Senate’s energy committee — warned CETA could increase electricity costs and threaten Washington’s affordability advantage.
Seven years later, as those requirements drive costly utility investments, the concerns about affordability deserve another look.
Consider what’s happening with Puget Sound Energy, which supplies electricity to some 1.26 million customers in eight Washington counties. In 2020, PSE charged approximately 9 cents per kilowatt-hour for the first 600 kilowatt-hours of residential electricity. By 2026, that rate had climbed to about 15 cents, or around two-thirds higher.
PSE is now requesting additional residential rate increases of 16.75% in 2027, 3.76% in 2028 and 8.81% in 2029. If those are approved by the Washington Utilities and Transportation Commission, PSE projects a typical residential customer using 800 kilowatt-hours monthly could pay $210 by 2029, up from approximately $159 now. An additional $50 each month would especially matter to families managing tight budgets and seniors on fixed incomes.
So how much of this is connected to CETA? PSE estimates the added cost of compliance at approximately $820 million for 2022-25. The utility also reports its annual power-supply costs increased from roughly $750 million in 2019 to about $2 billion.
Those figures deserve attention, but CETA isn’t responsible for every rate increase. Utilities also face rising electricity demand, infrastructure costs and the ongoing expense of maintaining reliable service. These factors all contribute to what customers pay.
PSE’s proposed capital investments illustrate the distinction. Approximately 42% would go toward acquiring new resources, including wind, solar, battery storage and natural-gas generation. Those investments support CETA requirements but also help meet growing demand and maintain reliability. The remaining 58% would fund existing infrastructure, transmission, customer operations and other system improvements.
Also, public utility districts and cooperatives have preferential access to Bonneville Power Administration electricity, much of it generated by hydropower. In contrast, PSE, as a private utility, must purchase power or develop its own generation resources, affecting the investments needed to meet state requirements.
These differences matter as CETA’s next major deadline approaches. Utilities must provide greenhouse gas-neutral electricity beginning in 2030 and 100% renewable or nonemitting electricity by 2045. That will require continued investment, and customers deserve to know what that means for their bills.
When lawmakers passed CETA, they didn’t ignore the affordability issue completely. While the law doesn’t cap electricity rates or automatically prevent higher bills, it established a cost-containment provision tied to a 2% threshold, intended to provide utilities with flexibility when compliance costs rise beyond that level.
PSE reports that its compliance costs for 2022 through 2025 reached 2.29%, which raises a question for lawmakers to consider: Does the 2% limit offer meaningful protection for the families and businesses paying those costs?
Washington can continue pursuing cleaner energy while protecting affordability and reliability. But it requires accountability and a willingness to make adjustments when costs become unreasonable. For that reason, legislators should take three steps when they meet in 2027.
First, require an annual public accounting of costs directly attributable to CETA, separate from other expenses driving electricity rates, so customers and lawmakers aren’t relying solely on utility estimates.
Second, examine the 2% cost-containment provision. Lawmakers should determine whether the law needs updating to prevent unreasonable compliance costs from being passed to consumers.
Third, establish a reliability checkpoint before CETA’s 2030 standard arrives. Lawmakers need to know whether utilities can comply while continuing to provide dependable electricity to households, employers and communities. At the same time, consumers deserve transparency about potential rate increases and whether the state’s cost protections are working.
I support Washington’s transition to cleaner, more sustainable energy, but it needs to happen without giving up the affordable, reliable electricity that has long been one of our state’s greatest advantages.
