Washington has managed to come up with another immigration proposal that exposes the hypocrisy of BOTH political parties. Republican Senator John Curtis of Utah and Democratic Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona have introduced legislation that would protect employers from certain civil and criminal liabilities for knowingly employing illegal workers.
The legislation is S. 5197, the State-Sponsored Visa Pilot Program Act of 2026. It would establish a new W visa allowing states to sponsor foreign workers according to local labor demands. The program would initially provide each state with 5,000 visas, with additional allocations based on population and other factors. Visas could last up to three years and be renewed. The bill also creates a process through which certain undocumented immigrants who were physically present in the United States on December 31, 2016, could apply for legal status after paying a penalty of at least $1,000 and satisfying other requirements. The politicians call this a pragmatic solution to labor shortages. Buried within the legislation, however, is a provision that would protect employers who supplied employment records for those applications from liability under federal employer-sanctions law for the workers’ prior unauthorized employment. That is the part Washington would prefer nobody noticed.
The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 made it unlawful for employers to knowingly hire unauthorized workers. The purpose was obvious. Forty years later, Congress is considering legislation that would weaken accountability for certain employers who violated those rules. Why should a company that knowingly ignored the law receive protection simply because it now provides paperwork to help a worker obtain legal status? What happened to the rule of law that politicians invoke whenever they want to impose another restriction upon the public?
Immigration is an economic issue involving labor, wages, productivity, and the movement of capital. There is an enormous difference between attracting skilled immigrants who contribute to economic development and creating a labor market in which businesses can disregard immigration law to obtain workers. Companies naturally seek to reduce operating costs. But when employers can hire unauthorized labor and then lobby Washington for legal protection, the government is creating an incentive to violate the very laws it claims to enforce. The businesses that complied with the rules are left competing against those that did not.
Senator Bernie Moreno of Ohio criticized the proposal, arguing that Congress should be doing precisely the opposite. He said the bill protects employers who knowingly hire illegal workers and then expect taxpayers to absorb the consequences. His point goes directly to the economic incentive. If Washington wants to reduce illegal employment, it must address the demand created by employers willing to violate the law. Punishing only the worker while protecting the business that offered the job leaves the underlying incentive intact. The government cannot claim to be serious about immigration enforcement while simultaneously creating exemptions for the companies that benefit from unauthorized labor.
The hypocrisy becomes even more apparent when considering how aggressively Washington enforces other financial regulations. An American small-business owner who fails to remit payroll taxes can face severe penalties. Employers must comply with wage laws, workplace safety requirements, tax reporting, and countless federal and state regulations. Yet Congress is discussing a special protection for businesses that knowingly employed people without authorization. The government is perfectly capable of enforcing rules when it wants revenue. Suddenly, when influential industries need labor, the same political establishment discovers the virtues of leniency.
The broader problem is the complete lack of consistency in immigration policy. One administration encourages expansive entry policies, the next promises mass enforcement, and Congress repeatedly introduces exceptions and special programs that leave businesses uncertain about the rules. Employers who follow the law incur the costs of compliance, while those willing to take risks may gain a competitive advantage. Then the political establishment proposes another program to regularize the situation. That is hardly a stable foundation for an economy. A country needs clear laws, predictable enforcement, and an immigration system designed around its actual economic requirements rather than the demands of whichever industry has the strongest lobbyists.
I have no objection to legal immigration that strengthens the productive economy. America has benefited enormously from talented people who came here to build businesses, develop technology, and contribute to society. But there is a tremendous difference between establishing lawful channels for workers and retroactively protecting employers who knowingly ignored existing requirements. If Congress believes the immigration laws are economically unsound, then change them openly. Do not bury protections for past violations inside legislation advertised as a solution to labor shortages.
What makes this proposal especially revealing is that it has bipartisan sponsorship. Washington cannot agree on how to control spending, address the national debt, or restore confidence in government, yet politicians from opposing parties can cooperate when employers want access to foreign labor and relief from legal consequences. Everyone wants cheap labor, and both sides are prepared to turn a blind eye to the companies that deliberately choose to hire non-citizens to save on payroll.
This legislation has not become law, and Congress still has an opportunity to remove the employer protections. But the fact that such a provision was introduced demonstrates how disconnected Washington has become from the public it supposedly represents. The average American is expected to follow every regulation and pay every tax while politically connected industries seek exceptions to rules they find inconvenient. The politicians can call it immigration reform, labor flexibility, or economic necessity. The question remains the same: why should those who knowingly broke the law receive protection from the very government that wrote it?
