Dave Upthegrove, Washington’s commissioner of public lands, campaigned successfully for the job on the promise to preserve 77,000 acres of maturing state forests.
His unilateral plan was never financially responsible, given the constitutional obligations his office has to the state’s logging trust beneficiaries, including many rural schools. But now, as his own agency descends into a budget morass, Upthegrove has rightly pulled back on his campaign pledge.
If the commissioner wishes to conserve more lands from logging, he must obtain authority from the Legislature to bring in new forms of revenue, including carbon offset markets that place value on trees’ sequestration superpowers. But most importantly, he must find a way to ensure financial sustainability for the many local governments that depend on the millions of dollars generated by state timber revenue.
To recap, Upthegrove took office in 2025 and immediately paused more than 20 potential timber sales as part of a new conservation effort to save forests that naturally regenerated before World War II. He said he would maintain the funding those sales would generate by logging younger stands of trees.
As The Times editorial board has frequently noted, doing that meant DNR has to sell logging rights on more than twice as much acreage, as skinnier trees have far less economic value than older, biomass-rich ones do. It appears Upthegrove has finally come around to this reality.
“If conserving our most ecologically valuable forests threatens the financial stability (and) if our only alternative is to harvest two or three times as many acres in other areas then we’ve not solved the underlying problem,” he said at a news conference in late September. “We’ve simply spread it across the landscape.”
That realization comes better late than never. Next, Upthegrove should continue pursuing different revenue options that can keep some forests standing while maintaining funding for the agency and its many trust beneficiaries. That will be a tall task, given that carbon-offset markets pay pennies on the dollar compared to logging.
Earlier this month, Upthegrove led the Board of Natural Resources to raise DNR’s management fee for timber harvests. That will help, but only marginally. The commissioner cannot escape the reality that his push for more conservation will require fewer workers to conduct timber sales. That will mean shrinking the size of his agency. It’s also doubtful the Legislature, facing its own budget shortfalls across state government, will be in any mood to extend a financial lifeline to DNR.
Here’s the good news: Upthegrove still heads an agency that conserves about half of its 3 million acres of trust lands for spotted owl and marbled murrelet habitat, biodiversity, and clean air and water. He must ensure DNR continues to sustainably harvest the rest, in the interest of the many governments around the state that depend on them — including his own.
It took humility for the commissioner to scale back his plan; it will take persuading the Legislature for him to advance new ways to pay for conservation.
