Did Brooks Nader Pull A ‘Challengers’ Movie Plot At The US Open?

Brooks Nader was too hot to handle at the 2025 US Open, so she probably needed two men to take the heat! 

A source recently spilled the tea on the  Sports Illustrated Swimsuit model’s romantic escapades, claiming she dated the finalists from the tennis tournament.

Brooks Nader’s interest in dating multiple men first made waves in August after one of her sisters claimed she had “a little roster” of suitors.

According to a source, the US Open tournament was a buffet of potential suitors for Brooks, and she chose the best of the crop as her romantic partners. The lucky men were tennis rivals Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner, a plot similar to the 2024 hit movie, “Challengers.”

The source’s claims matched the confessions of Grace Ann Nader, who revealed her older sister had “a little roster” of suitors. She broke the news late last month during their appearance on SiriusXM’s “Page Six Radio.”

Grace Ann noted there were several players on the media personality’s list, alleging that she was seeing men from “every field and court.” She claimed NBA players did not make the list and teased Brooks’ romance with Sinners, noting one of the suitors’ names “rhymes with winner.”

Following Grace Ann’s comments, Brooks appeared on “Jimmy Kimmel Live!” to promote her new reality TV show, “Love Thy Nader.” When the late-night talk show host asked about her relationship with Sinners, she avoided giving a direct answer.

“Is this, like, an interrogation? I’m so scared right now,” Brooks joked before adding, “You’re close… you’re warm.” Days after this interview, Grace Ann changed her tune about her older sister’s romantic escapades.

On Wednesday, September 10, Grace Ann told E! News at the Raising Cane’s NYFW Show that Brooks wasn’t dating Sinner. Instead, she claimed the model was in a relationship with the Italian tennis player’s biggest rival, Alcaraz.

Grace Ann confirmed Brooks and Alcaraz’s relationship, saying, “The rumors are true…Dating is such a loose term. But I do know he’s the man of the hour.” She implied their romance was serious, noting the Spanish tennis player had been introduced to the Nader siblings.

Alcaraz has met Brooks’ other sisters, Mary Holland Nader and Sarah Jane Nader, but Grace Ann hasn’t had the pleasure of an introduction. She noted she was “dying” to meet him and described the tennis champion as “such a cutie.”

Before her alleged ties to tennis players, Brooks was married to Billy Haire, an advertising executive. Life&Style Magazine reported they first met in 2015 following the media personality’s relocation to New York City.

Thanks to their disastrous first date, Brooks and Haire nearly did not make it down the aisle. The model recalled barely getting through their dinner due to a stomach disease she didn’t know she had. The condition caused her to run off after “projectile vomiting everywhere.”

She noted Haire thought she was uninterested and made her escape amid their date; however, they cleared the misunderstanding and had more dates. They were together for three years before Haire proposed to Brooks, and they tied the knot in December 2019.

Sources confirmed the end of their marriage in May 2024, revealing Brooks and Haire had amicably separated after months of living apart.

Following her divorce, the media personality was romantically linked to Greek Prince Constantine Alexios, NFL icon Tom Brady, and her “Dancing With The Stars” partner, Gleb Savchenko.